We are always buying your sports cards!

Steel City Collectibles is always buying trading cards, including unopened/factory-sealed hobby and retail boxes and cases, high-end singles and graded cards, authenticated autographs, and common autographs and non-manufacturer relic cards in bulk. View our most wanted buys and start your sale today!

View Our Buy List!

Selling your cards online has never been easier!

1. Submit your sale

Browse our most wanted list to see what we're currently buying and at what price! Add the items you have for sale, choose how you want to be paid and submit your sale online!

2. Ship your items to us

Once we accept your sale, we will provide you with the address to ship your items to us. Please pack your items securely to prevent any damage in transit.

3. Get Paid!

Once your items arrive at our warehouse and are checked in by our buying specialists, we will send your payment using your chosen method! Selling your cards online has never been easier.

We are also buying the following:

Single Trading Cards

We're buying your high-end, vintage or insert cards worth over $100. Let us know what you have!

Pokemon and Gaming Cards

View our buy list to see our offers for gaming cards, including Pokemon and Magic: The Gathering unopened boxes and cases!

Non-Sport Cards

We're also looking to purchase any non-sport cards, TV and Movie cards, entertainment cards and more!

Autographed Memorabilia

We're looking for high-end certified autographs and memorabilia from big names such as Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Marilyn Monroe and more.

Qualifying Common Game Used & Autograph Cards

Players must be in Major League Team Uniforms. We are currently buying up to 20,000 of each style.

Please Note: Minimum shipment for payment or website credit is $200 worth of cards.

Sport Auto* GU*
Baseball $1.25/ea $1.25/ea
Basketball $1.00/ea $1.00/ea
Football $1.00/ea $1.00/ea
Hockey $1.00/ea $1.00/ea
Racing $0.50/ea $0.50/ea

Manufactured Patches

Please be aware that manufactured patches are not event or game used and therefore carry a value of $0.00.


Non-qualifying cards from 2000 and up, including minor leagues, Team USA, Pacific, Press Pass, Sage, etc, will be purchased at $0.40 per. Please separate by sport and do not ship cards in toploaders, screwdowns, magnetics or semi rigids. Soft sleeves are okay.

Any questions about what is qualifying or non-qualifying please include in the form below.

We are now buying your Panini Rewards Points!

  • Paying $0.05 per Panini point!
  • Minimum of 1,000 points
  • For more information and to get started, please e-mail Billy at [email protected]!
  • Meet our buyers!


    Autographed Memorabilia


    Unopened Boxes and Cases


    Single Cards

    Deal in person

    Bring your collection and stop by our booth at one of these shows!

    Dates Show Location
    July 27, 2022 - July 31, 2022 National Convention Atlantic City, NJ
    Sept 23, 2022 - Sept 25, 2022 Valley Forge Valley Forge, PA
    Oct 21, 2022 - Oct 23, 2022 Chantilly Chantilly, VA
    Dec 2, 2022 - Dec 4, 2022 Valley Forge Valley Forge, PA